Showing posts with label Coding Rules. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Coding Rules. Show all posts

Tuesday, September 13, 2016

Changes to Diabetes Coding Rules Create Challenges

In Q1 2016, Coding Clinic published a question and answer about "Diabetes with Associated Conditions".

On the surface, this new rule seems great--here's an excerpt from AHA's Coding Clinic:


Question:

"The ICD-10-CM Alphabetic Index entry for 'Diabetes with' includes listings for conditions associated with diabetes...Does the provider need to document a relationship between the two conditions or should the coder assume a causal relationship?"

Answer:

"... the term "with" means "associated with" or "due to," when it appears in a code title, the Alphabetic Index, or an instructional note in the Tabular List,... The classification assumes a cause-and-effect relationship between diabetes and certain diseases of the kidneys, nerves, and circulatory system....

It is not required that two conditions be listed together in the health record. However, the provider needs to document the linkage, except for situations where the classification assumes an association ...When the provider establishes a linkage or relationship between the two conditions, they should be coded as such. .... The fact that a patient has two conditions that commonly occur together does not necessarily mean they are related...."

All of this sounds like it should make things easier for both physicians and coders.  However, the opposite can be true.

As coders, it's our job to educate physicians on coding rules.  But I think this Coding Clinic ruling, and other similar ones, as potential minefields.  Physicians, by the very nature of their jobs, have to keep current with a large amount of very complex information.  Educating physicians on a rule like this has the potential to backfire.

The physician is unlikely to go to the ICD-10 and check the code title, then to the Alphabetic Index, and  continue on to search for instructional notes in the Tabular list to determine if the term "with" is present.  That may lead them to assume that the rule applies in cases where it doesn't.

There is no harm in documenting the association between two diseases, but there can be tremendous harm (in an audit situation) in failing to document that association if the rule does not apply.

So, how can we best educate our physicians?  I think that explaining that there are some limited cases where a causal relationship is assumed is a good approach.  But with that explanation, physicians must also be told that the majority of the time, a  causal relationship is NOT assumed, and that trying to remember which is which is difficult for coders who do this all day long.  The safest approach is to state the causal relationship, which ensures that coders can code what the physician actually means.  Give them examples--and make sure those examples demonstrate how this can be done without significantly increasing their workload.  By simply adding a few words, the physician can convey their clinical judgement that one disease cause another--for example "CKD 4 2o DM2" clearly shows the physician's diagnosis that type 2 diabetes mellitus caused the patient's stage 4 kidney disease.  And it means that doctors don't have one more thing to remember.

While telling our physicians about these rules in detail may seem like a good idea, it can increase the likelihood of errors.


What coding and educational challenges do you face?  Do you have ideas for helping providers navigate documentation issues?  Be sure to leave us a comment, or send ideas you would like to share to coding@scanhealthplan.com.


Monday, December 5, 2011

A Very Frequently Asked Question

We frequently are asked about "where CMS says" one thing or another.  First, you have to remember that CMS can't and won't address every possible situation.  By applying common rules and logic, you can usually know what CMS would do in a given situation.  One question we get a lot is:

Our doctors want to know why they can’t just write “250.40 –diabetes with renal manifestations” in the record and code 250.40—and where CMS says they can’t do this.

Our answer to this question is as follows:

CMS doesn’t write the rules for ICD-9 by themselves—and it would be impossible to write a rule for each and every possible situation that can occur.  The Official Coding Guidelines make it clear that a diagnosis must be supported by the medical record, and must affect the care of the patient.

The rules for ICD-9 are written by the four cooperating parties – the American Health Information Management Association, the National Center for Health Statistics, the American Hospital Association, as well as CMS.  All official interpretations not found in the coding guidelines are the responsibility of the American Hospital Association, via Coding Clinic.

A short diagnosis code description (like diabetes with renal manifestations) is just that—a description.  The word “manifestations” is not a diagnosis, it’s a category of conditions, and the physician is required to describe what disease in that category exists.  A physician can no more support an ICD-9 code by writing the description than they can support an E/M code by writing its description. 

Writing “Office or other outpatient visit for the evaluation and management of an established patient, which requires at least 2 of these 3 key components: A detailed history; A detailed examination; Medical decision making of moderate complexity. Counseling and/or coordination of care with other providers or agencies are provided consistent with the nature of the problem(s) and the patient's and/or family's needs. Usually, the presenting problem(s) are of moderate to high severity. Physicians typically spend 25 minutes face-to-face with the patient and/or family” does not support a 99214, it’s a description of a 99214. Similarly, in order to support a diagnosis, the physician must document what’s wrong with the patient.

So, with diagnosis coding, the physician must document in the medical record what is actually wrong with the patient--not a category of what's wrong with the patient.